The rule permits teams to substitute a player during a match, allowing for tactical adjustments which Ashwin believes add value to the game. He also refuted claims that it hinders the development of all-rounders, asserting that players still have the freedom to pursue both batting and bowling.
During a conversation on Kris Srikkanth’s YouTube show Cheeky Cheeka, Ashwin explained, “Why I think the Impact Player rule is not so bad is because it gives a little more value for strategy.”He acknowledged the criticism that the rule might discourage the development of all-rounders but argued, “In this generation, they don’t do it [batters bowling and vice-versa].It’s not like they’re discouraged because of the Impact Player rule.”
The Impact Player rule has sparked debate since its inception. It allows teams to extend their batting line-ups, potentially leading to higher scores. Indian skipper Rohit Sharma has voiced concerns, suggesting that the rule may hinder the growth of all-rounders in Indian cricket.
Nevertheless, Ashwin cited examples to bolster his argument. In Qualifier 2 of IPL 2024, Sunrisers Hyderabad played against Rajasthan Royals. Hyderabad posted a score of 175/9, and Rajasthan fell short by 36 runs. A crucial moment came when Sunrisers introduced Shahbaz Ahmed as an Impact Substitute. He took three wickets for just 23 runs, significantly influencing the match’s outcome.
“Sunrisers [Hyderabad] brought in Shahbaz Ahmed as an Impact Player [vs Rajasthan Royals, after hitting 175 for 9 batting first]; he went on to become a match-winner [with 3 for 23]. When dew has the potential to make games one-sided, teams bowling second get an extra option as a counter,” Ashwin explained.
Ashwin elaborated on how the rule enhances competitiveness and dynamism in matches. “If you’re batting second, you can tactically make a substitution by offloading the extra bowler for a batter. Games are tighter, and an extra player is getting to play,” he said. He also noted that, aside from venues like Kolkata or Mumbai where scores are typically higher, other locations have seen more balanced contests with scores in the 160-170 range.
Ashwin highlighted how the Impact Player rule has facilitated the rise of several players in Indian cricket. “Shahbaz Ahmed, Shivam Dube, most importantly, Dhruv Jurel… If not for the Impact Player rule, he may have never gotten the chance. So the emergence of a lot of players has happened. I’m not saying that’s the only way for players to emerge, but it’s not so bad,” he said.
While opinions on the Impact Player rule vary, Ashwin’s comments highlight the strategic depth it can add to the game. The rule encourages innovation and creates new avenues for players to showcase their skills in the competitive landscape of the IPL.